The root causes of Dadri

The root causes of Dadri

By Dhiraj Nayyar | 3 October, 2015
A misunderstood secularism and disdain for rule of law have exacerbated prejudice and violence.
It is convenient to pin the blame for every communal incident on Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Let’s be clear. The murder of Mohammed Akhlaq by a lynch mob in Dadri is indefensible. Any murder is indefensible. There is no such thing as a “noble” or “justifiable” motive for heinous crime. But let’s also acknowledge that communal prejudice and communal violence precede the ascent of Modi. In fact, they predate the birth of an independent India. What is perhaps tragic is that 68 years of freedom haven’t ushered in the modernity necessary to erase that prejudice and violence. And the problem isn’t going to be resolved by a stern statement or two from PM Modi. 
Society needs to introspect as much as politicians do. That said, no society has ever been totally free of fringe elements or extremist violence. The challenge is to ensure that it remains “fringe” and doesn’t mainstream itself. The danger in India is that what might be considered fringe elsewhere is far too acceptable by elements of the mainstream. The problem is that Mahesh Sharma (who called the Dadri incident an accident) and Asaduddin Owaisi (who calls it premeditated) are bigots masquerading in the mainstream.
Fundamentally, the principle of secularism has either been misunderstood or misappropriated. The Nehruvian version (also the Western notion) depended on society moving away from its strong religious moorings (and accompanying prejudices) as industrialisation happened and modernity took over. Perhaps it was the failure of the Nehruvian economic project that communal prejudices and grievances grew rather than evaporated with time.
Of course, cynical politicians played their part. The BJP and its predecessors (Jan Sangh, Hindu Mahasabha) may have been open about their majoritarianism, but the so-called secular parties led by the Congress always found it convenient to let the fires of communal prejudice and violence simmer from time to time. It is difficult to think of any political party, which has openly campaigned in favour of genuine secularism in recent decades. Even now, does any Congress leader have the guts to put their career on the line and step into the cauldron of Dadri? Still, the fallout from deep-seated prejudices and fears might have been contained if India had given greater weight to the rule of law. It is because individuals and groups feel that they are beyond the pale of the law that they act to destroy and murder. In other advanced, societies it is the rule of law which prevents the fringe from coming anywhere near the mainstream. There are serious consequences for heinous crimes which act as a deterrent. In India, governments (politicians, bureaucrats and police) have given the rule of law short shrift. 
Unsurprisingly, society too cares little for the one principle which could safeguard life and property. If there was even a semblance of rule of law in Uttar Pradesh, a mob would not have dared to lynch a man with such impunity on the suspicion that he had slaughtered/eaten a cow. Incidentally, it is the “secular” Samajwadi Party which is responsible for the rule of law in UP. If indeed Akhlaq had committed an illegal act, the correct response would be to report him to the authorities. The BJP, in its wisdom, is legislating against cow slaughter in several states. But where in those laws is there a provision which grants a free licence to kill an offender? Perhaps Nehru was right. The only solution to a society’s prejudices was economic development. Modi needs to double down on the task of delivering prosperity in rapid time. It will probably be more effective than a rap on the knuckles to some in his parivar.

There are 17 Comments

A beautifully written nonsensical meaningless sans-purpose article.I dont know why Sunday Guardian even published it.

A tacit & articulate article. Job well done.

Till Bihar election it will go on. There is so much money in politics that every political party wants that holy grail. They will stoop to any extent. Be it murder murder or mass killings in the name of riots. Congress thinks only it has the legitimate right to rule India. So for them to be without power is like fish out of the water. Country can go to hell

Rule of law is a good thought but that is where it will remain till we spend on building the judiciary as a percentage of GDP. Ours is a country with massive needs and intangible needs like justice are not the priority. And by that I mean speedy justice that happens within a year or two and final justice including appeals to higher courts right up to the supreme Court happening within a period of five years. To achieve this sort of thing we will have to build thousands of additional lower courts, appoint thousands of judges, each with their perks & residences. Proportionate increase in higher courts & judges. The workload of a judge has to come to maximum 5 cases a day from present 100-150. Only then will rule of law happen. It's a pipe dream otherwise. This is a determination & budgetary problem, not a social one.

The writer is trying to find excuses for Mr Modi, But it was he who appointed a person like Mr Sharma as a minister and made the fringe mainstream. No minister in a congress goverment-whatever its other faults- would have dared to make such a statement and and expect to continue in office. Mr MOdi's long silence til he was prodded by the President himself, spoke for itself. Economics has little to do with the incident.

Mr Modi abdicated his position as the leader of the Country in favour of the President through his disturbing tendency to remain silent on such vital issues threatening the unity and integrity of the Country. It is high time Mr Modi calls the bluff of the fringe elements so as to send the message that he means the business of running the State in unequivocal language.

The solution to prejudice may not be found in economics but in culture. - Buy Dapoxetine Online <a href="">Doxycycline Hyclate 100 Mg</a> - Priligy Dapoxetine <a href="">Purchase Doxycycline</a>

<a href=>Dapoxetine</a> <a href="">Doxycycline</a> - Precio De Priligy <a href="">Buy Doxycycline</a>

Incredibly educational... looking onward to visiting again [url=]nfl 17 news[/url]

say thanks to so mucha lot for your website it aids a great deal fut coins

Thanks for furnishing this type of amazing details cheap hut coins

Add new comment

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.