Lessons India should learn from China

Lessons India should learn from China

By T.V. Mohandas Pai | 28 January, 2018
India did not invest adequately in infrastructure—only 4.7% of GDP, where the need was 6.5%. China over invested at 8.7%, while it needed only 6.5%.

In 1950 both China and India were rebuilding their economies after a long period of war and unrest. Both independent, one communist and the other democratic. India was in much better shape, the largest economy in Asia, with a relatively sophisticated economic system. China went its own way, plunging into the chaotic and destructive Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward. 

By 1978, after the death of Mao, it was an economy going nowhere with a bloated population and great poverty. India had turned its back on its long history of capitalism and adopted a socialist economic model with state control. It grew only around 3.5% per year, with a population growing at 2.5% unable to tackle its challenges while it watched the miracle growth of Japan, Germany and South East India. With government control, increasing corruption and increasing civil dissatisfaction it too was going nowhere.

In 1978, China opened up, inviting foreign capital, promoting its coastal areas for investment, freeing agriculture from state control, introducing a one child policy and investing in infrastructure. Today, it is a $12.5 trillion economy, the second largest in the world and at $22.5 trillion in PPP, the largest economy. India opened up in 1991 after an economic crisis, grew impressively in dollar terms at 8.8% per annum and is today a $2.5 trillion economy, way behind China. 

What are the lessons from China’s growth for India? 

China first focused on investment in labour intensive industries to create jobs for its huge labour force, in textiles, garments, toys, light engineering and assembly, electronics, etc. It created special economic zones, whole districts next to the coast with different laws for business. The massive increase in employment created the resources from increased consumption and taxes to invest in infrastructure. It enabled the growth of large firms which could invest. Its banks lent freely to state owned enterprises too. China had a decentralised economic model, where the provinces made many economic decisions, granted incentives, marketed themselves and nurtured industries, with almost no red tape. The key target was job creation. China invested massively in skill development and in her universities. It created very many new cities, promoted urbanisation and benefited immensely. 

 China soon attracted over $1.5 trillion of FDI, becoming the factory of the world, the largest global importer and exporter and through mercantilist policies created a foreign currency kitty of over $4 trillion and managed its currency to keep its advantage. It used a sophisticated supply chain through Hong Kong to dominate global trade. It shifted over 400 m people from the land to the city and factories. It now boasts of some of the most sophisticated industries. 

India incentivised capital intensive industries through its incentives and tax subsidies and discouraged job creation. Today industry pays an effective tax rate of 25% in corporate tax, while services sector pays 30%. It discriminated against large companies, reserving goods for the MSME. Its labour policies inhibit hiring and job creation. Labour intensive industries like garments suffer from excessive tax and regulations and over the last 25 years, India’s labour intensive industries declined globally, whereas it had all the resources to dominate the world.  

India did not invest adequately in infrastructure—only 4.7% of GDP, where the need was 6.5%. China over invested at 8.7%, while it needed only 6.5%. As a result, India’s supply chain costs are at 14% of GDP, creating a high cost uncompetitive economy, while China is at 6%, creating a competitive low cost economy. The recent GST will remedy it somewhat, but huge investment in infrastructure is needed. India did not invest in her cities, discouraged urban planning, depriving her cities of autonomy and good governance, creating an urban crisis. It championed the romantic notion of rural villages, failing to understand that rapid urbanisation was the future.

The lessons for India are very clear. 

Incentivise and increase investment in labour intensive industries to create more jobs. Remove restrictive labour regulations to increase job creation. Allow firms to grow faster in all areas by de-reserving goods for MSME and making them grow bigger. Reduce corporate taxes to 25% for all to increase internal generation of resources and reduce capital intensity by reducing depreciation rates. Incentivise job creation by special tax breaks. Increase investment in infrastructure to at least 6.5% of GDP, release investment resources by divestment in state owned mature infrastructure assets.

Improve productivity of ports, reduce power theft, improve speed on highways and in railways and reduce the cost of doing business by removing unnecessary regulations. Keep a level playing field between Indian business and FDI. Allow investment in education by the private sector to improve skills and human capital, grant full autonomy to the top 200 universities to increase innovation. Above all, invest in her cities including in new cities to promote rapid urbanisation, which could enable delivery of civic services to improve quality of life, give freedom to cities and towns to govern themselves and create new jobs. 

China has many lessons for us. Their companies will dominate the world in future. India should learn from the Chinese success as it is the only country with a 1.3b+ population, which started off in 1950 with a similar economic and social structure and succeeded in dominating the world.

T.V. Mohandas Pai is Chairman, Aarin Capital Partners. 

There are 2 Comments

URGENT GENUINE LOVE-SPELL TO GET YOUR EX BOYFRIEND/GIRLFRIEND OR husband/wife BACK FAST. I have something to share with you!!! There is a great joy in my heart which I want to share with everyone. My name is Caroline Webb from united States. I had a misunderstanding with my lover last year which led us to break up and he never wanted to hear my voice again. He saw a beautiful woman which he find more prettier than me, but as time went on I met god Dr lucky He is a great spell caster. I contacted him through his email and explained everything to him. He said that I shouldn't worry, that my lover will come back to me on his knees begging for forgiveness before 24 hours.My greatest joy now is that he actually came back to me and fell on his knees begging for forgiveness, and today we are happy and he also cured my Sister's breast cancer. Do you have any problem? worry no more because Dr lucky can provide lasting spell solution to any problems:email him luckysolutiontemple@gmail.com or call him +2348070980389 or add him on whats- app +2348070980389 (1)If you want your ex back. (2)You want to be promoted in your office. (3)If you want to be cured of HIV, Cancers and other diseases. (4)You want to be rich. (5)You want your husband/wife to be yours forever. (6)If you need financial assistance. (7)If you went to get pregnant.

Are you going through a mid-life crisis for example a divorce,miscarriage,can't find love no need to worry covenantsolutiontemple@gmail.com can help you with any personal need.many people will try to sugar coat the truth and give you false hope but not Dr.Ewan he will tell you the truth and nothing but the truth and keep your hopes high and alive so, please dont waste your time and hope on somebody who doesn't deserve it.contact this man via this email if you really need to get your problems solve covenantsolutiontemple@gmail.com or call or add him on whatsapp on +234905735398 or check out his webpage http://allwomenstalk.com/p/58034af4f725a97d108b4569.

Add new comment

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.