The revenge of the samosa

The revenge of the samosa

By M.J. Akbar | 16 January, 2016
The 13.5% value added tax on samosa and bhujia in Bihar opens up space for something more deadly than anger: ridicule.

There is no retribution harsher in politics than the revenge of the samosa. Every politician knows this much. The surprise is that Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, and his patriarch, Super Chief Minister Lalu Yadav, both veterans of electoral battles as well as administration, forgot a fundamental principle of democracy: you never feed the treasury from the menu of the poor. The poor have little by way of luxury, and a low-cost evening savoury is one of their few moments of pleasure in a tough day.
In budgeting parlance there is something called a “sin tax”, a regular resource base for any government. This is a tax on items like liquor and cigarettes. You could, if in a particularly puritan mood, stretch the sin-range to luxuries like expensive hotels. But no finance minister in his, or her, senses ever squeezes money from the beedi.
It is too early for the Bihar electorate to get angry with a government it has just placed in office, but
the 13.5% value added tax on samosa and bhujia opens up space for something more deadly than anger: ridicule. The sarcasm—and no one does that better than the Bihari—will cut across class, creed and caste because the samosa is unique in its appeal across distinctions, a true item of mass consumption. Indians invented fast food long before multinationals discovered its appeal. We also had the good sense to keep fast food a home industry. It is a business through which a poor man can also earn a living. The producer and consumer are often within the same socio-economic zone.
Nitish Kumar and Lalu Yadav must share the barbs; for while the origins of this decision lie indisputably in the CM’s office, the finance minister of Bihar belongs to Lalu Yadav’s party. This is one instance when Lalu Yadav cannot chortle in private at what Nitish Kumar does in public.
The samosa’s revenge was evident soon enough, and Nitish Kumar is now trying to mitigate the political offence by suggesting that he only intended the tax for a costlier form of packaged samosa. It is not the afterthought which will stick, but the thought. This amendment is obviously a fudge, because bhujia is also on the punitive list.

The samosa’s revenge was evident soon enough, and Nitish Kumar is now trying to mitigate the political offence by suggesting that he only intended the tax for a costlier form of packaged samosa. It is not the afterthought which will stick, but the thought. This amendment is obviously a fudge, because bhujia is also on the punitive list. It also gets curiouser and curiouser. Why tax mosquito repellents, for instance?

It also gets curiouser and curiouser. Why tax mosquito repellents, for instance? Mosquitoes do not vote. And they can be occasionally lethal. Of course, this does reveal that mosquito repellents have a huge market in Bihar, and the government expects high returns. Revenues from Patna alone could pay for a fat department of government. The state is infested with mosquitoes. It is equally obvious that there is not much industry in Bihar which can generate tax revenues; there is nothing else to tax. Government, therefore, is trying to profit from its own past failure. Word will spread — as rapidly as mosquitoes.
One does wonder about how such silly mistakes are made by persons with experience, whether in politics or bureaucracy. It could be because they do not have to pay for either samosas or bhujias when in power. The cost of afternoon chai and accompaniments comes from the administrative budget.
The British Prime Minister David Cameron, who belongs to the refined-dined aristocracy of his land, once tried to get psychologically cosy with the masses by standing outside a stall and eating Britain’s version of the samosa, the Cornish pie. Cameron made a mess of the staged event, for he had no idea how to eat humble pie. As a public relations exercise it was a disaster, and the press did not let him forget this opportunism in a hurry. But Cameron was never going to tax the pie, even though he has a finance minister, George Osborne, who has made it a mission to balance the books. If Osborne cannot be credited with as much success in this objective as he might have hoped for, at least you cannot fault him for trying.
The samosa-bhujia tragi-comedy comes at a time when the Lalu-Nitish government is just beginning to lose a bit of sheen for reasons that are definitely not funny. Crime is back with a vengeance in the state, as criminals get political patronage. There is a growing sense of fear in rural areas. Officials are getting orders from the parallel Lalu Yadav network, and they understand better than anyone else where real power sits. By itself the samosa’s revenge may have been contained, but in an environment that is encouraged by both memory and experience, the samosa adds significant collateral damage to the reputation of Nitish Kumar.

There are 3822 Comments

It needs a special brand of cussedness to tax the 'Samosa', an ubiquitous humble snack and everyone's delight, particularly the 'Aam Aadmi', for whom every party and its leaders pretend to fall over backwards. One completely fails to see the logic and any inane 'explanation', like the 'packed in a box' is only a joke, if not a hoax, and can only be an exercise in a crude cover up for the people of Bihar.

I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I certainly enjoyed every bit of it. I have got you book marked to look at new things you post… my site; <a href="">manual cigarette</a>

Hi there, I discovered your blog by means of Google at the same time as searching for a similar subject, your website got here up, it seems good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.[X-N-E-W-L-I-N-S-P-I-N-X]Hi there, simply was alert to your blog through Google, and located that it's truly informative. I'm going kaffeebecher to go - be careful for brussels. I'll appreciate if you proceed this in future. Numerous other people will be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

I love reading blogs like this! Causes also and me to feel a warm satisfying emotion educated! Thanks so much! My site <a href="">gold IRA rollover</a>

When someone writes an paragraph he/she maintains the image of a user in his/her mind that how a user can know it. Thus that's why this piece of writing is perfect. Thanks! Also visit my blog post ... سيو -

We're a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your site offered us with helpful information to work on. You have done a formidable task and our entire neighborhood can be grateful to you. Also visit my web-site: <a href="">Manual book</a>

This is my first time pay a quick visit at here and i am really impressed to read everthing at alone place. My homepage; Foods to Eat to increase sex Drive -

Gorgeous! You do not come by info like this easily and that I am happy! Keep it-up people! Feel free to visit my blog post :: average weight loss (<a href=""></a>)

Along with the car sales, the Japanese used car sellers also supply the dismantled parts of the vehicles in cube containers of size 20ft or 40 ft. So, you are not required to move from one dealer to another for ideal model. It is available in two versions of petrol and diesel and has been a very reasonable price. Also visit my weblog ... ビットコネクト -

Spectacular! You don't come by info such as this simply roof repair and installation - that I am so pleased! Maintain it up people!

Our latest addition to the limousine fleet is the 7 passenger Cadillac Escalade. Be smart and savvy when negotiating the interest rate for new cars and don't just sign on the bottom line. Go to the search tool and search for keyword like used cars in Bangalore, pre owned cars and second hand cars in Bangalore. my weblog - <a href="">sextoy kopen</a>

This blog supplies just beneficial data and that I am subscribing to it-this instant! Thank you guys! Check out my website ... Fat Pussy -

This certainly qualifies as you, although it is so difficult to find useful information nowadays. Making will surely return soon and content! My webpage: deerfield sport fishing ( -'%20rel='external%20nofollow )

I needed to take some time to state my appreciation towards you and this blog that was wonderful! Loving it! Stop by my page; eiffel tower bedding -

Wow! This blog really presses with me and I could say nothing less than I enjoy it! Feel free to surf to my weblog :: skin structure (<a href=""></a>)

I needed to make an effort to specific my passion towards you and this website that was great! Loving it! Visit my web blog :: wallets online (<a href="">Kassie</a>)

I am basically pleased with this particular website and that I wanted to take some time to thankyou from my heart's bottom! Stop by my blog - chapter 7 bankruptcy (<a href="">Chara</a>)

Then Passbook can be a excellent system for your creativity, In case you have ambitions for developing magnificent wallet tips. It is one of the best returns on investment you can make in online marketing. The key to victory and raking in profit is by betting on a low limit poker game. Here is my webpage ... judi online -

I enjoy reading websites such as this! Causes educated and in addition me to experience a warm enjoyable emotion! Many thanks so much! Take a look at my web page: Teak outdoor furniture manufacturer -

Wow! <a href="">see this interesting article</a> web site actually presses with me and that I could claim nothing less than I love it!

I simply could not keep without saying thankyou from the bottom of my heart after reading this website that is awesome! Feel free to visit my webpage: Human Passenger Drones -

I just could not leave without saying thankyou from your bottom of my heart after reading this blog that is wonderful! Also visit my blog post <a href="">Email address test</a>

Beautiful! That you don't come by data similar pop over to these guys - this simply and I am not so ungrateful! Preserve it up guys!

Gгeetings from Colorado! І'm bored at work ѕo I decided to browse your website on my iphone during lunch Ьreak. I enjoy the info you providе here and can't wait to take a look when I get home. I'm shocked at how fast your Ƅlog loaded on my mobile .. I'm not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyաays, supᥱrb blog! Here is mу website <a href="">judi poker</a>

I needed to make an effort to express my gratitude in your direction which amazing blog! Caring it! Here is my site :: <a href="">computer characteristics</a>

Por sorte, os fungos vivem nas camadas exteriores da pele e não invadem seu organismo. Aqui é meu página de teia - web site (<a href=""></a>)

Breathtaking! That you don't come by information like this simply and I am not so ungrateful! Maintain it-up guys! Here is my web page ... attend college thousands ( Richelle - )

Gang run printing gives the same advantages as offset printing with a significantly lower expense. My homepage ... Printing VIP -

I'm basically satisfied with this blog and that I desired to take some time to many thanks from my heart's base! Here is my webpage cure tinnitus (<a href="">Alfredo</a>)

This website offers only important data and I am checking to it-this instant! Thank you guys! My web blog; <a href="">real estate sales llc reviews</a>

I desired to take the time to specific my gratitude towards this wonderful website and you! Caring it! My blog post; ( Lourdes - )

I love reading websites similar to this! Causes me to feel a rewarding that is warm emotion and in addition enlightened! Thankyou so much! Take a look at my blog post ... healthy living; <a href="">Amparo</a>,

This excellent website definitely has all of the information I needed concerning this subject and didn't know who to ask. My web-site - muskelaufbau -

It is not no problem finding information that is important today, but this undoubtedly qualifies together. Leaving will definitely comeback soon and pleased! my weblog :: real estate buzz - - -

Hi, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so i came to “return the favor”.I am attempting to find things to improve my web site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!! my page :: garcinia cambogia vibe -

Gorgeous! You don't come by information like this simply and that I am not so ungrateful! Preserve it-up people! my website ... <a href="">sewer repair</a>

hi! Me parece muy atinada tu parecer sobre este motivo. Desde hace cierto tiempo que estoy interesado en esto y también intento aclararme un poco las dudas sobre este tema. La participación que has desarrollado me ha semejado muy buena, no obstante creo que se podría ahondar un tanto más y de igual modo poder evidenciar diferentes dudas que aún poseo. De todos modos, mil gracias por tu colaboración. Estaré atento a cercanas publicaciones que elabores. Mil gracias. Saludos. My site - campamentos, campamentos de verano, campamentos de verano baratos -

What's up to every body, it's my first pay a quick visit of this weblog; this website contains amazing and in fact excellent material in favor of readers. Here is my homepage ... <a href="">Manual book</a>

Beautiful! You don't come by info such as this quickly and that I am gracious! Preserve it up people! My weblog; fat loss; - ,

I simply couldn't leave without saying thanks from your bottom of my heart after scanning this brilliant blog! Also visit my blog - <a href="">mlm lead generation</a>

This website offers only useful information and that I am subscribing to it-this instant! Thank you guys! Feel free to visit my site sodium meals ( - )

I've been surfing online more than 2 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all website owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the net will be a lot more useful than ever before. Also visit my homepage :: <a href="">repair book. manual book review</a>

Right now it looks like Movable Type is the preferred blogging platform out there right now. (from what I've read) Is that what you're using on your blog? Here is my blog post; Skeet Reese Spinning Reel Reviews -

Includes more than enough chairs, 6 meditation chairs, folding tables, Capacity 35 people seated. Stop by my blog :: pisciniste lyon, <a href=""></a>,

Good information. Lucky me I came across your blog by chance (stumbleupon). I've saved as a favorite for later! productos bancarios -

Wow, this piece oof writing is fastidious, my younger sister is analyzing these things, thus I am goking to inform her. Here is my web blog ... <a href="">filme Streamen</a>

I recently could not leave without saying thanks from the bottom of my heart, after scanning this awesome website! My webpage :: finding a life coach for yourself ( - )

It's so difficult to find valuable information but this truly qualifies as you. Departing pleased and will undoubtedly come back soon! Here is my homepage new bags (<a href=""></a>)

Only important information is provided by this blog and that I am subscribing to it-this instant! Many thanks people! Also visit my blog; lot for sale in cebu -

I'd like to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this site. I am hoping to view the same high-grade blog posts from you in the future as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my very own blog now ;) Here is my blog post ... article sur les pénalités de référencement -


Add new comment

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.